Livable Later

Practical home changes for staying safely at home

Entries, stairs, and doors

When a stairlift is the wrong tool

A downstairs bedroom, a vertical platform lift, or an elevator solves different problems. A stairlift solves only a seated ride on a stair that can spare the width.

Livable Later editorial team · Updated November 1, 2026 · About 7 minutes

A stairlift is a specific answer: a person who can sit and transfer needs a ride on a stair that still works as a stair. A lot of families buy one because it is the product that showed up first. The better question is which activity is trapped upstairs. If it is sleep, the answer may be a bedroom downstairs. If it is a wheelchair that has to change floors, the answer is a platform or a shaft, not a chair. If it is one high entry step, the answer is a ramp or a regraded walk, not a lift on the porch.

This guide sorts those tools. It is not a clinical judgment about whether a particular person should climb. An occupational therapist and a physician own that judgment. A contractor owns the structure. You own the choice of which problem you are paying to solve.

Move the life, not the person

The cheapest vertical transportation is none. If the bathroom, the kitchen, and a room that can become a bedroom are already on one floor, the stair is a storage problem, not a daily one. The first-floor bedroom guide covers egress windows, smoke alarms, and the door widths that make that switch real. Do that inventory before you price machines. A spare dining room with a powder bath nearby has rescued more households than a curved rail.

Laundry is the errand that keeps people on stairs with a basket in both hands, which is the CDC's nightmare drawing: objects, no hand on the rail, poor sight line. Moving the laundry, or moving the hamper to the floor where the person dresses, removes trips even when the bedroom stays upstairs. The laundry guide is the small version of this idea.

Sometimes the honest alternative is a different house or a first-floor apartment. AARP's 2015 cost article quoted a remodeler who tells owners that widening a typical hallway can run so high, in his market tens of thousands of dollars, that selling is the rational project. That is one contractor's report from 2015, not a rule. It is a reminder to price the whole pattern of barriers, not one product. A lift upstairs does not widen the bathroom door.

Platform lifts

A vertical platform lift is a small open or enclosed cab that rises a few feet or a full story beside the stair or at a porch. The rider rolls or steps on and rides standing or seated in a wheelchair. An inclined platform lift rides the stair itself on a rail, which means the stair has to be wide enough for the platform and for the walking path you still need. AARP's same 2015 article reported practitioners' figures of about $20,000 for vertical or inclined platform lifts, installation included, and only if the stair already works. Widening a stair is extra and often structural. Treat $20,000 as a dated reported example, not a bid.

ASME A18.1 is the standard that covers these lifts and stairway chairlifts. Residential elevators fall under a different standard, ASME A17.1, when they are true elevators. Ask which standard the proposal is built to, what the travel height limit is, and whether your state allows that lift in a house. Some jurisdictions allow a vertical platform lift for a porch and refuse it as the path between two full stories. The building official's answer beats the brochure.

Platform lifts need a pit or a ramp at the bottom, a solid pad, a door or gate with interlocks so the gate will not open when the platform is away, and electrical power on a dedicated circuit. They need a plan for a power failure. Many will lower under battery power. Confirm that, and confirm whether someone who uses a wheelchair can get out at the bottom without help. The lift also needs maintenance. A porch lift that dies in January is an entrance that died.

The footprint is the surprise. The platform has to be large enough for the wheelchair you actually own, plus a few inches, and there has to be level space to roll straight on and straight off. A turn at the door of the lift eats the porch. Draw the chair's path with tape on the floor before anyone pours a pad.

Elevators, and why the prices do not match

A residential elevator is a cab in a shaft, with a pit or a holeless design, a machine, and a controller. It is the right tool when more than one person needs floor-to-floor access, when a wheelchair is permanent, and when the house can give up the floor area. It is the wrong tool when one person needs a temporary ride and a straight stair is sitting there unused.

Historical price lists from 2015 disagree with each other because they describe different objects: a cab dropped into a shaft that was framed in advance, a pneumatic unit in an open foyer, or an exterior tower that is really a small addition. Those dollar figures are a decade old. Do not budget from them. Use the disagreement as a warning, and ask every bidder to say whether the price includes the shaft, the pit, the electrical, the machine room or the machine-room-less controller, the cab finish, the permits, and the annual test. A cab price without a shaft is a catalog, not a project.

Shafts want to stack. A closet over a closet is the usual candidate. Ducts, plumbing stacks, and beams do not move for free. An external tower avoids some of that and adds a foundation, a roof, and a new door on each floor, plus heat so the cab does not become a cold lock. Pneumatic vacuum elevators are a third type, often shown in open foyers. They have their own structural and code questions. Do not choose from a photograph. Choose from a code official who has seen the model and a structural carpenter who has seen your joists.

Elevators need a fire and entrapment plan: a phone or a monitored alarm in the cab that works when the house power fails, a key for rescuers, and a household that knows not to force the door. They also need money every year. Budget service the way you would budget a furnace contract.

What not to substitute

A rolling office chair on a stair is not on this list. Neither is a wheelchair pushed by a willing relative up a flight, which injures the relative and the rider. Outdoor stair climbers and tracked devices exist as equipment a person brings to a building. They are not a residential entrance, they take skill, and they are the wrong thing to improvise from a video. If someone is suggesting one, talk to the therapist who knows the person's balance before anyone spends money.

A ramp solves a short rise. It does not solve a full story unless you have a very long run or a switchback and a yard to put it in. The math is unforgiving: 8 feet of rise at 1:12 is 96 feet of ramp plus landings. That is a different building. Do the arithmetic before you fall in love with a boardwalk.

Grab bars and a better handrail solve a stair the person can still walk. They do not solve a stair the person cannot walk. Be precise about which of those you have. A week of the person descending with a therapist or a careful family member, hand on a real rail, tells you more than a showroom.

A sorting list

Match the tool to the barrier

  • Daily life can move downstairs, and a bathroom is already there or can be added: do that first, and read the bedroom guide for egress and alarms.
  • The person walks but the stair is dark, loose, or has one rail: fix light, carpet, and rails before any machine.
  • The person can sit and transfer, the stair is wide enough, and both floors must stay in daily use: price a stairlift, and read its limits.
  • A wheelchair has to change levels a short distance, or move between floors in a shaft the code allows: price a platform lift against ASME A18.1 and the local official.
  • Full wheelchair access for a household, with floor area to give up: price an elevator with shaft, power, alarm, and service written out.
  • The rise is at the front door only: stop looking at lifts and start on a zero-step entry or a real ramp.

Funding programs treat these differently. A VA HISA grant, for example, is aimed at medically necessary access into the home and to bathrooms, with lifetime caps that will not buy most elevators. The VA guide and the other ways to pay spell out what is actually written in the program rules. Do not buy a lift because a salesperson said a grant would reimburse it. Confirm the money before you sign.

Sources